Readers who will have snagged a copy of Steig Larsson’s newest thriller The Girl Who Played with Fire (it’s out in the UK, translated from the original Swedish; US edition is coming in July) will have noticed that female protagonist Lisbeth Salander satisfies her nascent interest in spherical astronomy with the help of a book titled “Dimensions in Mathematics,” written by one L. C. Parnault and apparently published by Harvard University Press in 1999.
Unfortunately for those of you who would like to follow in Lisbeth’s footsteps and penetrate the “dimensions of mathematics” for yourselves, you’ll have to turn somewhere other than the work of the esteemed Dr. Parnault, for as far as we can tell, and if our memories and our computers have not completely failed us, HUP has in fact published no such work, in 1999 or at any other time. Thus it seems that Mr. Larsson, whose Scandanavian crime fiction has won him a good deal of posthumous fame, leaves us with more than just fictional mysteries. We can only speculate about what Dr. Parnault would have been like, had we actually known or published him, and as for the contents of his mythical “Dimensions,” well, that’s an even greater mystery. For all we know, it could be the key to the universe or something, and now it’s gone missing! So if you’ve spied a copy of “Dimensions” in some musty back-alley secondhand shop, or know the whereabouts of our friend Dr. Parnault, or if somehow you yourself are Dr. Parnault, just, um, get in touch.
No, it doesn’t exist, but there are plenty of good reading books on numbers and in particular, FLT. I was slightly disappointed that the only math person referred to in ” … fire” was Pierre de Fermat himself. The person who made first major contribution to a proof was a French girl, Sophie Germain who encountered prejudice all her life, and even after it. She was an exceptional person whose exploits are reminiscent of Lisbeth’s. Her story is inspirational and Lisbeth would have loved her.
funny, but a quick search in amazon for “dimensions in mathematics” gives us as a first result the “math book” which sounds very much the same as Lisbeth’s book.
The book in the novel may be based in part on “Mathematics — From the Birth of Numbers,” written by the late Swedish author Jan Gullberg and published in 1997. See http://www.amazon.com/Mathematics-Birth-Numbers-Jan-Gullberg/dp/039304002X/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1273581115&sr=1-1. It fits Larsson’s description of the book as “a history of mathematics,” “a brick” (over 1,000 pages), “not strictly a textbook,” and “written by an author who was both pedagogical and able to entertain the reader with anecdotes and astonishing problems”.
“Mathematics — From the Birth of Numbers” is a great book which is as close to Salander’s as as I’ve ever seen. I’ve had it for years and still enjoy picking it up and reading sections. It has proper mathematical explanations, including the equations, which is something that, sadly, most such books lack.
Here’s another comprehensive “History of Mathematics” by Boyd and updated by others including Isaac Asimov…this seems more in line with the fictional book (that is referred to by Larsson.)than one referenced above closer to the same title but more about math education…
Ref. the proof of “Fermat’s Last Theorem” you should read
“Unlocking the Secret of an Ancient Mathematical Problem” by Amir D. Aczel published in the USA by Four Walls Eight Windows in 1996 ISDN 1-56855-077-0.
I went looking too! Funny! My son tested at 189 on a test IQ type, so I thought It would be good to give him. Oh well, C’est la vie! Great books though – 1/2 way through number 3. And PS there may be alot of fiction, but at age 61 I also believe there is alot of reality disguised in there!
For anyone specifically interested in Fermat’s Last Theorem I found a book on Amazon called Fermat’s Last Theorem: Unlocking The Secret of An Ancient Mathematical Problem by Amir D. Aczel. I’ve yet to read it so I’m unsure of how good it would be but it seems solid.
Do you reached this book?I looked for Turkey but it was very expensive.(it is 160 dolars!)Really looks like an interesting.I want to read this incredible book.
Here is my solution – I was reading it in the wee small hours because I couldn’t put it down – which may help to explain a few things!
Can’t remember exact wording: She giggles and then there is something to the effect that it is more a question for philosophers or something like that.
“She GIGGLES” – it is a joke – it is funny! – get it?
… as in 1 1=”a window” all kids learn that – get it yet?
Well, fine, ok: what do horrible, unsolvable maths questions do? they put you to sleep, right? and z3 is in fact “zzz” which any child can tell you means “sleep” so x3 y3 = “zzz”.
x2 y2 = z2 is pythagorus theorum for a right angled triangle and completely solvable: apparantly x3 y3 = z3 is not.
I don’t know the maths of trying to solve it but late at night reading the book, she is a maths genious who could not solve the problem, until she “gets the joke and giggles” – I actually just came on line to see if someone else had “discovered” the answer and reached the same conclusion I did – I laughed out loud reading it because my sleep deprived brain actually made the connection between being tired and “zzz”.
x3 y3 = z3 is a parody and the answer is funny.
there is a Simpsons episode that had a maths joke with the solution being rdr2 (which is rdrr, or – say it – r d r r – “ha de ha ha”)
ps just in case: ( 1 1=window: if you write 1 with touching the 1 then write another 1 touching the other side of the 1 then write the = as one line above the and one below, you have drawn a window )
of course I could have it completely wrong but I don’t think so and I like it! She is a maths genious and recognises it can’t be solved and that the mathematician was having a laugh, all these serious people trying with great seriousness to solve the problem and they don’t realise it is a joke – she has just got the joke!
It may be Larssen, or it may be the translation, but reading what his fictional book has to say about mathematics is like reading Michael Connelly on computers. The tone is false, and there are some howlers in the parts quoted from the book (e.g., equations don’t have “roots”, they have “solutions”; roots belong to polynomials). If the book really existed, it wouldn’t be worth reading.
Comments :
6 Last comment by chris from sallysfriends.net in Copenhagen 24 October 2009. Started by : Salander fanatic in salander ville 16 October 2009
29 comments on “Dimensions in mathematics”
Apparently it never existed. Too bad. Here is a blog entry from Harvard University Press
(http://harvardpress.typepad.com/hup_publicity/2009/02/dimensions-in-mathematics-a-phantom-a-chimera.html):
Dimensions in Mathematics – a phantom, a chimera
Readers who will have snagged a copy of Steig Larsson’s newest thriller The Girl Who Played with Fire (it’s out in the UK, translated from the original Swedish; US edition is coming in July) will have noticed that female protagonist Lisbeth Salander satisfies her nascent interest in spherical astronomy with the help of a book titled “Dimensions in Mathematics,” written by one L. C. Parnault and apparently published by Harvard University Press in 1999.
Unfortunately for those of you who would like to follow in Lisbeth’s footsteps and penetrate the “dimensions of mathematics” for yourselves, you’ll have to turn somewhere other than the work of the esteemed Dr. Parnault, for as far as we can tell, and if our memories and our computers have not completely failed us, HUP has in fact published no such work, in 1999 or at any other time. Thus it seems that Mr. Larsson, whose Scandanavian crime fiction has won him a good deal of posthumous fame, leaves us with more than just fictional mysteries. We can only speculate about what Dr. Parnault would have been like, had we actually known or published him, and as for the contents of his mythical “Dimensions,” well, that’s an even greater mystery. For all we know, it could be the key to the universe or something, and now it’s gone missing! So if you’ve spied a copy of “Dimensions” in some musty back-alley secondhand shop, or know the whereabouts of our friend Dr. Parnault, or if somehow you yourself are Dr. Parnault, just, um, get in touch.
Posted by Steve Y in Ann Arbor, MI ,
No, it doesn’t exist, but there are plenty of good reading books on numbers and in particular, FLT. I was slightly disappointed that the only math person referred to in ” … fire” was Pierre de Fermat himself. The person who made first major contribution to a proof was a French girl, Sophie Germain who encountered prejudice all her life, and even after it. She was an exceptional person whose exploits are reminiscent of Lisbeth’s. Her story is inspirational and Lisbeth would have loved her.
Posted by scormus in zurich, switzerland ,
Hmm… I wish it existed… I would have loved to read it… Seemed great when Lisbeth read it in the series…
Posted by B-nita in Sweden ,
Darn! and I wanted to get the book for aa Christmas present for my son!
Posted by Sarah in Philadelphia ,
The book that Lisbeth Salander was reading in the 2. book.
Dimensions in Mathematics
The exact book do not exist, but i’ve found a book which look very simular.
Philosophical Dimensions in Mathematics Education
Here is a link to get it.
http://www.elounge.com/pages/ProductDetails.aspx?ProductIndeks=4221012
Posted by Emil in Denmark ,
that is’t that same
Posted by a in a ,
i think it’s a different book
i will read this
and what’s a shame
i wont this book(DIMENSIONS IN MATEMATICS)(I want it)
Posted by b in b ,
funny, but a quick search in amazon for “dimensions in mathematics” gives us as a first result the “math book” which sounds very much the same as Lisbeth’s book.
http://www.amazon.com/Math-Book-Pythagoras-Milestones-Mathematics/dp/1402757964/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1269971161&sr=1-1
Posted by Ben in – ,
From the description of the book, it sounds similar to “A History of Mathematics” by Victor J. Katz.
Posted by Martin ,
The book in the novel may be based in part on “Mathematics — From the Birth of Numbers,” written by the late Swedish author Jan Gullberg and published in 1997. See http://www.amazon.com/Mathematics-Birth-Numbers-Jan-Gullberg/dp/039304002X/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1273581115&sr=1-1. It fits Larsson’s description of the book as “a history of mathematics,” “a brick” (over 1,000 pages), “not strictly a textbook,” and “written by an author who was both pedagogical and able to entertain the reader with anecdotes and astonishing problems”.
Posted by Boreal ,
Gullberg… mmm… sometime, somewhere I have heard this name before…
Posted by Mmac in Genoa ,
ha ha ha thank you
Posted by sasidharan.s in salem india ,
“Mathematics — From the Birth of Numbers” is probably the closest book that we’ll be able to find to the fabled “Dimensions in Mathematics”.
Posted by Morgan in San Diego, California ,
“Mathematics — From the Birth of Numbers” is a great book which is as close to Salander’s as as I’ve ever seen. I’ve had it for years and still enjoy picking it up and reading sections. It has proper mathematical explanations, including the equations, which is something that, sadly, most such books lack.
Posted by Islwyn in Montgomeryshire ,
Who knows the answer to the proof for X3 Y3 = Z3.
Fermat’s last theorem?
Posted by McNamara in Denver, CO ,
Here’s another comprehensive “History of Mathematics” by Boyd and updated by others including Isaac Asimov…this seems more in line with the fictional book (that is referred to by Larsson.)than one referenced above closer to the same title but more about math education…
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0471543977/sr=1-2/qid=1295037772/ref=olp_product_details?ie=UTF8&me=&qid=1295037772&sr=1-2&seller=
Posted by jriverrun in San Antonio, TX ,
John Wiles (Harvard) proved it in the 1990s
There are so many mathematicians out there, some of them can right books too .. Anyone up to the challenge to write that book and close the gap?
Posted by David Hiskiyahu in Antwerp; BE ,
Ref. the proof of “Fermat’s Last Theorem” you should read
“Unlocking the Secret of an Ancient Mathematical Problem” by Amir D. Aczel published in the USA by Four Walls Eight Windows in 1996 ISDN 1-56855-077-0.
Posted by Colin J. Spencer in Spalding U.K. ,
Apologies for typo in ISDN No. it should be 1-56858-077-0.
Two other very interesting books unrelated to Fermat but which I’m sure Salander would have liked are:-
1) “Mathsemantics – Making Numbers Talk Sense” by Edward MacNeal. ISDN 0-670-85390-9
2) “The Man who Loved Only Numbers” by Paul Hoffman
ISDN 1-85702-811-2.
Posted by Colin J. Spencer in Spalding UK ,
I went looking too! Funny! My son tested at 189 on a test IQ type, so I thought It would be good to give him. Oh well, C’est la vie! Great books though – 1/2 way through number 3. And PS there may be alot of fiction, but at age 61 I also believe there is alot of reality disguised in there!
Posted by Gammy Sparkles in Colorado Springs ,
For anyone specifically interested in Fermat’s Last Theorem I found a book on Amazon called Fermat’s Last Theorem: Unlocking The Secret of An Ancient Mathematical Problem by Amir D. Aczel. I’ve yet to read it so I’m unsure of how good it would be but it seems solid.
http://www.amazon.ca/Fermats-Last-Theorem-Unlocking-Mathematical/dp/1568583605/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1301672995&sr=1-2-spell
Posted by Cameron Bell in St. John’s ,
Do you reached this book?I looked for Turkey but it was very expensive.(it is 160 dolars!)Really looks like an interesting.I want to read this incredible book.
Posted by ,
By the way my name is Gizem.My name is means in English mystery:)
Posted by Gizem Yumuk in in Turkey,Bursa ,
Your name is Gizem and it means English mystery?
And is that a hard G (like Gate or Get) or a soft G (as in Germany) ??
Posted by Cass in Christchurch, NZ ,
Here is my solution – I was reading it in the wee small hours because I couldn’t put it down – which may help to explain a few things!
Can’t remember exact wording: She giggles and then there is something to the effect that it is more a question for philosophers or something like that.
“She GIGGLES” – it is a joke – it is funny! – get it?
… as in 1 1=”a window” all kids learn that – get it yet?
Well, fine, ok: what do horrible, unsolvable maths questions do? they put you to sleep, right? and z3 is in fact “zzz” which any child can tell you means “sleep” so x3 y3 = “zzz”.
x2 y2 = z2 is pythagorus theorum for a right angled triangle and completely solvable: apparantly x3 y3 = z3 is not.
I don’t know the maths of trying to solve it but late at night reading the book, she is a maths genious who could not solve the problem, until she “gets the joke and giggles” – I actually just came on line to see if someone else had “discovered” the answer and reached the same conclusion I did – I laughed out loud reading it because my sleep deprived brain actually made the connection between being tired and “zzz”.
x3 y3 = z3 is a parody and the answer is funny.
there is a Simpsons episode that had a maths joke with the solution being rdr2 (which is rdrr, or – say it – r d r r – “ha de ha ha”)
ps just in case: ( 1 1=window: if you write 1 with touching the 1 then write another 1 touching the other side of the 1 then write the = as one line above the and one below, you have drawn a window )
of course I could have it completely wrong but I don’t think so and I like it! She is a maths genious and recognises it can’t be solved and that the mathematician was having a laugh, all these serious people trying with great seriousness to solve the problem and they don’t realise it is a joke – she has just got the joke!
Posted by Jess in Wellington, NZ ,
“The answer was so disarmingly simple. A game
with numbers that lined up and then fell into place in a simple formula that was most
similar to a rebus.
Fermat had no computer, of course, and Wiles’ solution was based on mathematics
that had not been invented when Fermat formulated his theorem. Fermat would never
have been able to produce the proof that Wiles had presented. Fermat’s solution was
quite different.
She was so stunned that she had to sit down on a tree stump. She gazed straight
ahead as she checked the equation.
So that’s what he meant. No wonder mathematicians were tearing out their
hair.
Then she giggled.
A philosopher would have had a better chance of solving this riddle.
She wished she could have known Fermat.
He was a cocky devil.”
Posted by Jess in Wellington, NZ ,
It may be Larssen, or it may be the translation, but reading what his fictional book has to say about mathematics is like reading Michael Connelly on computers. The tone is false, and there are some howlers in the parts quoted from the book (e.g., equations don’t have “roots”, they have “solutions”; roots belong to polynomials). If the book really existed, it wouldn’t be worth reading.
Posted by Cliff in Portland ,
Sheesh ! Just enjoy the book ..or not